The incoming House Speaker Hakeem Jeffries said in a recent interview with The New York Times that “within the first 100 days, I think the most decisive step that we can take relative to the situation in the West Bank is to move the West Bank Settler Violence Protection and Prevention Act.”
His statement illustrated how the incoming Congress is likely to put pressure on Israel regarding the continued chaos and violence in the West Bank. Jeffries said that the Act focusing on “settler violence” would have strong support within the House Democratic Caucus.
His comments reflected the increasing conundrum Israel has faced over the last few years regarding the violence in the West Bank. Much of the violence was caught on film and in photos over the last few years, which showed gangs of men clashing with Arabs in various localities. Even though the violence was condemned by politicians in Israel and by the Israel Defense Forces, it has continued.
On November 22, the IDF soldiers and Israel Border Police said that officers were dispatched to the areas of Deir as-Sudan, Deir Abu Masha'al, Kafr Malik and At-Tuwani following reports and footage that showed vehicles being set on fire and graffiti being sprayed in the area.
“The IDF strongly condemns acts of violence of this nature, which harm public order, divert forces from their primary missions, and hinder ongoing operational and counterterrorism activities,” the IDF said. In other recent incidents of violence, extremists were accused of attacking Israeli police in the southern West Bank on November 20.
On November 19, CNN said that “a 72-year-old Palestinian woman was shot and killed by Israeli settlers in front of her home in the occupied West Bank on Tuesday, according to Palestinian officials and eyewitnesses. Fadda Fuhaidat was shot in the head after midnight near the city of Jericho, where Israeli settlers took over eight Palestinian homes two weeks ago.”
Netanyahu minimizes Jewish extremism in West Bank
Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said in December 2025 that the violence was “a handful of kids.” He told Fox News that media coverage had become bloated.
“We actually located it. It’s about 70 kids. They’re not from the West Bank.” He went on to argue that “they’re actually teenagers who come from broken homes, and they do things like chopping olive trees, and sometimes they try to burn a home…I can’t accept that. That’s vigilantism. I’m taking that out.”
However, the acts of violence didn’t stop. If it was just a handful of kids, it was unclear why they weren’t detained and charged. In August, 2026 the prime minister again condemned “criminal acts of violence” after attacks in the Palestinian West Bank villages of Qusra and Jalud.
He said it was a “handful of rioters” and claimed that their actions were “causing a huge injustice to the law-abiding settler public, hindering the IDF in fulfilling its missions, and harming Israel’s standing in the world.” He said the security forces had worked quickly and seized three vehicles used by the handful.
Speaking at the UN in September, the prime minister reiterated that the perpetrators were a “handful of juvenile delinquents.” However, it was not clear if the alleged kids and juvenile delinquents from “broken homes” had been charged. Netanyahu said that media coverage was focused on this violence.
“What they cover is a handful of juvenile delinquents, about 150 in number, who throw stones, who chop down olive trees, occasionally they light some fires. I can't stand that. I won't stand for vigilantism. We're a country of law. So we put our Shin Bet on them. But that's what they call settler violence. And the number of casualties a year? Maybe two or three.”
Why aren't we seeing more arrests?
It appeared the number grew from “70 kids” to “about 150 in number.” The videos of the incidents also increased, showing attacks by gangs of youth, often with masks, who pile into pick-up trucks on Shabbat. Israelis have been shocked by these scenes, feeling that the white pick-up trucks remind them of the scenes from October 7.
Where did the kids and juvenile delinquents get access to expensive trucks that often cost several hundred thousand shekels in Israel? Where did they get a driver’s license in a country where most people obtain licenses only after the army, and then at great expense after many lessons?
If only a handful of kids are driving around on Shabbat in pickup trucks, then it would seem easy to detain them. Most Jews in observant West Bank communities don’t drive on Shabbat. This is the conundrum Israel faces, and it has not changed throughout 2026. The attacks have also targeted a wide range of people. Heidi Levine, a Washington Post journalist, was attacked in October.
Israel’s President Herzog spoke with her. “As President of the State of Israel, I strongly condemn this outrageous and shocking violence, both the terrible attack you endured and other grave incidents of violence, such as what took place today in Taybeh,” he said.
He described how the attack had “weighed heavily on my conscience throughout Shabbat, and I express my deep sorrow and apologize for what you went through.” He said, “Law enforcement authorities must use every means at their disposal to investigate thoroughly, apprehend these lawbreakers, and bring them to justice to the fullest extent of the law.”
The chances that Congress may move to focus more on the violence in the West Bank appeared to be a kind of ‘own goal’ or unforced error by Israel. Israel has the security resources to stop the violence.
In many cases, the IDF is called into areas of the West Bank when clashes occur. However, the IDF doesn’t have the police powers to investigate, detain, and prosecute. All the army can do is try to separate people. It’s not a police force. However, the IDF has been used as a kind of police force in the West Bank for years.
Everyone condemns the violence, so why does it continue?
This creates a catch-22 for Israel. Israeli authorities condemn the violence and call for prosecutions. Israeli politicians condemn the violence. The IDF condemns it. Everyone condemns it. And yet, it doesn’t stop. There doesn’t even seem to be a plan in place to address it, such as a rapid-reaction force of police and Border Police to deal with clashes.
That being said, the IDF did work hard to coordinate the olive harvest season this year. “Over the past several weeks, security forces, in coordination with Civil Administration officers, have been operating to prevent friction in the area and enable a proper and safe harvest for all residents of Judea and Samaria,” the IDF said last week.
More than 150 coordinated events took place, and millions of liters of olive oil will be produced from the harvest. “The areas of friction receiving significant media attention account for only a few percent of the olive harvest areas in Judea and Samaria,” the IDF said.
This once again raised the recurring issue. Authorities in Israel sometimes argued that the media is blowing these stories out of proportion. However, if they knew the media is focusing on just a few places, why not deploy more forces there to pre-empt chaos?
For instance, if it’s common that a few pick-up trucks full of hooligans are going out in just a few locations in the West Bank on Shabbat, looking for clashes, why not just stop these two or three vehicles?
It shouldn’t be that hard, with Israel having some of the best hi-tech in the world, to spot a pick-up truck with numerous people in the back, which is clearly a violation of the law. Since we don’t see those pickup trucks full of young men anywhere else in Israel, it stands to reason it can be enforced in the West Bank if it can be enforced in Kiryat Gat and Karmiel.
Yashar party Chairman Gadi Eisenkot wrote on November 22, “the night of arson in Judea and Samaria is Jewish terrorism in every sense of the word, and it must be called what it is. Sabotage by extremist groups setting fire to vehicles and homes undermines regional stability, endangers lives, and severely damages the national security and foreign relations of the State of Israel.”
Knesset member Yoav Segalovitz wrote that “the arson and violence in Judea and Samaria tonight are Jewish terrorism in every sense. These are serious acts that endanger human lives, and they must be fought with determination.” Segalovitz is a former senior law enforcement officer and a member of the 26th Knesset representing Ra’am.
The violence in the West Bank is condemned, and yet it has continued. It’s also predictable. A lot of the violence appears to happen on Shabbat. Much of it seems to target the same areas and villages, again and again. The inability of the authorities to use tools to deal with it leads to more pressure on Israel abroad.
The cynical calculus in Jerusalem has often been that it’s worth not confronting the violence by a fringe few, because far-right parties may be angered. Instead, the narrative on the Right, or far-right, often blamed the media for highlighting the incidents. Mainstream Israel, including almost all the media in Israel, doesn’t appear to agree with this sentiment. They think the lawlessness can and should be dealt with.
As recently as a few years ago, the kind of lawlessness was kept in check. It remains to be seen whether Israeli officials will put the lid back on the kettle or pressure from abroad will increase. Pressure from abroad may have the unintended consequence of making some more stubborn to confront the problem locally. This will be another feedback loop into the conundrum.