US President Donald Trump and the Republican Party weren’t the only ones to take a shellacking in the Bluenami midterm elections. Israel and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who makes no secret of his Republican leanings, were also gobsmacked by the waves.
If there was anything resembling a bipartisan consensus in this election, it was that Bibi must go, and the US-Israel alliance needs a major overhaul.
Trump and Vice President JD Vance wasted no time putting blame for the Republican losses on Israel.
The president tried to distance himself from the expected anti-Israel wave by announcing a deal with Netanyahu to halt military aid by the end of the year. “They don’t need it,” he explained. The prime minister didn’t confirm, and the White House offered no details. The Obama-era aid agreement runs through 2028.
Vance interpreted the election outcome as Republicans saying they want to “change our relationship with Israel.” He got an immediate enthusiastic endorsement from the president’s son, Donald Trump Jr. The president agreed, telling 60 Minutes, “there’s a great dislike, incredibly, for Israel.” He then took full credit for Israel’s survival: "Israel would not exist except for Donald Trump.”
A definition of tzoris is when Trump and Abdul El-Sayed, the newly elected far-left Democratic senator from Michigan, agree on halting military assistance to Israel. The senator-elect would go much further, though, including restricting or even blocking Israeli access to American technology and weapons.
El-Sayed, who will be the first Muslim in the Senate, ran on a stridently anti-Israel, anti-AIPAC (American Israel Public Affairs Committee) platform. The pro-Israel lobby group, through its PACs, spent some $30 million trying to defeat him.
Virtually his first move on winning was to call for replacing the Democratic Senate leader, Chuck Schumer, one of Israel’s most prominent supporters, with one of Israel’s most strident critics, Sen. Chris Van Hollen of Maryland.
Schumer had backed El-Sayed’s primary opponent but endorsed him for the general. Van Hollen had backed the challenger from the outset.
'An obstacle to peace'
Schumer had already moved beyond the days when he called himself “Bibi’s best friend in Washington.” More than two years ago, he said the prime minister had “lost his way” and must be replaced because he had become “an obstacle to peace.” He supports military aid restrictions.
Van Hollen, 67, has given several reasons for challenging Schumer, 75. He said the midterm elections showed voters want change, ignoring that Schumer was the architect, recruiter, and fundraiser for the Senate victories.
But Israel appears to be an underlying factor. Van Hollen has been one of the most outspoken critics of Israel’s Gaza campaign, accusing it of pursuing policies that worsen the humanitarian crisis. He wants to restrict US military assistance and levy sanctions in response to Jewish settler violence against West Bank Palestinians.
Van Hollen said he dropped his plans to run for president two years from now to unseat Schumer, but I suspect that if he loses his leadership bid, he will withdraw his withdrawal from the 2028 sweepstakes.
El-Sayed questions Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish state or “ethnostate,” as he called it. He does support the two-state solution, as do Schumer and most Americans. Netanyahu is unalterably opposed.
The Iran war and its economic impact at home were major factors in moving voters to the Democratic column. Trump and Vance sensed that coming and have hinted they feel Netanyahu pushed them into joining his long-sought war.
In the weeks before both countries’ elections (Israelis voted one week before the Americans), Netanyahu was talking about reigniting the war, a move seen to serve his political needs, not Israeli security.
Israel could also be a factor in electing the next Speaker of the House. Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, the Democratic leader and presumed shoo-in, is a long-time supporter of Israel with close ties to the Jewish community – like Schumer, he’s from Brooklyn – and may face a challenge for that reason.
A slight majority of Democrats voted this summer to cut military aid to Israel; next year the caucus will be more progressive and likely to increase the challenge. Similarly, the GOP is expected to be more isolationist.
Jeffries recognizes the wall-to-wall bipartisan support for Israel has vanished in the wake of Gaza and Iran. No longer ready to vote for unconditional aid to Israel, he has said, “The status quo is unacceptable, and we need dramatic change.”
He cited the treatment of Palestinians in the West Bank, the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, Jewish settler terrorism, and Palestinian statehood.
That is consistent with the bipartisan consensus on Capitol Hill for changing the bilateral relationship. The era of wall-to-wall support is history.
AIPAC's demands for unrestricted support wound up helping elect anti-Israel candidates because it set the bar too high.
A survey by the Chicago Council on Global Affairs concluded that most Americans support decreasing or halting aid to Israel.
An Israeli friend told me the other day, “I’m not sure the Israeli government really understands the gravity of what is happening.”
An American Jewish community leader added, “There can be no reconciliation with the Democrats until Bibi goes.”
Netanyahu’s longstanding decision to abandon the Democrats to focus on evangelicals, Republicans, and the Trump followers – not unlike AIPAC – has backfired.
Republican fortunes could turn around in two years with a pink wave, but Israel’s recovery will take much longer, even if Netanyahu is replaced by a more centrist and responsible government.
Sen. Chris Coons (D-Delaware), who is expected to chair the Senate Foreign Relations Committee next year, said restoring bipartisan support will require “Israel making changes in policy that move in the direction of our shared values.”
Just as Israel needs new leadership, so does AIPAC, which has emerged from the midterms weakened and tarnished. Politico has reported that it will enter the 120th Congress with fewer allies.
The organization had marched in lockstep with Netanyahu for many years, only to become a pariah for many lawmakers and candidates.
If it is to regain lost respect, it must return to its bipartisan roots, get out of the money game, and stop endorsing candidates, especially bad guys (like election deniers) just because they may vote right sometimes. That will require a complete top-down rebuilding.
Under its present leadership, the once highly respected lobby has lost credibility not only among Democrats but in the Jewish community where it was seen as protecting extremists who opposed most of the priorities of Jewish voters and supported an unpopular extremist Israeli government.
Israel also must win back American Jewry, which is becoming increasingly indifferent to its welfare.
A poll for J Street, AIPAC's leftist rival, found 72% of Jewish voters backed Democratic congressional candidates in this month’s election. A similar number support sanctions on Jewish terrorists.
My generation and my parents grew up in an age of a threatened Israel fighting for survival; our children and grandchildren know it as a swaggering, muscular, nuclear-armed regional superpower. David and Goliath have switched roles.
The writer is a Washington-based journalist, consultant, lobbyist, and former legislative director at the American Israel Public Affairs Committee.