Nir Hasson’s recent interview with South African jurist and International Court of Justice ad hoc judge Navi Pillay conclusively shows that no libel about Israel is too grotesque for Haaretz to print. Pillay was quite clear that in her view, Israel is perpetrating a genocide in Gaza.
For Pillay, this is the “only reasonable inference” from the killing of 75,000 civilians (note that she does not believe any of the Gaza casualties to be Hamas combatants) and the widespread destruction of the infrastructure in Gaza.
Pillay has a history of minimizing or even ignoring Hamas’ existence. In her words, when other countries faced terror, “They investigated, arrested the individuals concerned and put them on trial… And that is what the world expects Israel to do.”
That itself shows the unseriousness of Pillay’s analysis. She never explains how Israel could have sent its police force into the heart of Hamas-controlled Gaza and arrested Mohamed Deif and Yahya Sinwar. The UN Commission of Inquiry, headed by Pillay, similarly stated in its report that Hamas never posed an existential threat to Israel.
She is also incorrect on legal grounds. The post-9/11 world proves that states have the right to self-defense against terrorist organizations. Following the September 11 terrorist attacks, the UN Security Council passed 1368 and 1373, recognizing the right to individual and collective self-defense against the attacks. NATO activated its collective self-defense clause for the first time after 9/11.
In 2015, after ISIS carried out major attacks against the Bataclan in Paris and in Sinai, the UN Security Council adopted resolution 2249 authorizing states to take “all necessary measures” against ISIS.
According to established case law, genocidal intent must be the “only reasonable inference” from a pattern of conduct. In its Croatia v. Serbia decision, the ICJ dismissed claims of genocide occurring during the fall of Vukovar, in which Serbian forces carried out atrocities against Croats, because they were motivated by a military purpose.
Regarding a 1995 Croatian military offensive that led to the mass displacement of 200,000 Serbs, the Court explicitly held that “if the shelling of towns can be explained by military necessity or a desire to force a population to flee, then genocidal intent is not the 'only reasonable inference.'"
Pillay claimed that Israel supposedly targeted the al-Basma fertility clinic in December 2023 to prevent Palestinian births. Yet, as the IDF has repeatedly asserted, there is no indication that it ever carried out this strike.
As Salo Aizenberg has written: “The al-Basma IVF clinic accusation is one of the most sensational claims in the report, framed as evidence of genocide. Yet the only established facts are that the clinic sustained damage and embryos were lost. There is no verified date, no confirmed cause, no evidence that the IDF knew it was an IVF clinic, no evidence that it was specifically aware of nitrogen tanks within, and no evidence of intent.
"The possibility remains that it was the result of a misfired Hamas rocket, as in the well-documented al-Ahli Hospital explosion in October 2023. Even if IDF ordnance was involved, there is no evidence whatsoever that it was intentional.”
Pillay showed a profound ignorance of both the realities and the legalities of war. In fact, she is part of a trend of jurists pushing to rewrite the definition of genocide to essentially make war illegal. As Policy Exchange, a leading British think tank, has warned, such a redefinition will have a profound and negative impact on all democratic countries fighting dictatorships or terrorist groups.
The former Ukrainian foreign minister noted that Russia legitimized its invasion of Ukraine based on claims that Ukraine was perpetrating genocide against Ukraine’s ethnic Russian minority. Pillay and the ICJ are opening the door to justifying Putin’s propaganda.
'Public pressure in Western democracies affects foreign policy'
Policy Exchange’s experts wrote, “Western democracies are the intended audience of false claims of genocide, because public pressure in Western democracies affects foreign policy, whereas in autocracies it does not. Accepting these claims means letting tendentious notions propagate, undermining the moral basis of our foreign policy.”
The genocide libel is intended to prepare the ground for sweeping sanctions, boycott, and exclusion of Israel. It will also enable prosecution against Israeli officials, as well as supportive states like the US and UK, in countries with universal jurisdiction.
The claim that Israel is committing genocide is one of the oldest tropes of Cold War propaganda. The crematoria in Poland were barely cold before the Soviet Union and Arab states accused Israel of acting like, or even worse than, the Nazis. The widespread damage in Gaza has a simple explanation – the difficulties of fighting intense urban combat and Hamas’ weaponization of Gaza’s infrastructure. Pillay isn’t interested in the truth, however. Israel must make its case to those who are interested.
The writer, an advocate, is an international law researcher at Kohelet Policy Forum.