“There’s a great dislike, incredibly, for Israel.”
That was what the president of the United States said on 60 Minutes, explaining why his party lost both houses of Congress.
In the same interview, he said that without America, Israel would not exist, and that had he not struck Iran, “There would be no Israel right now.” In 2024, he warned that if he lost, Israel would cease to exist within two years.
Israelis owe America real gratitude. Harry Truman recognized the Jewish state 11 minutes after David Ben-Gurion declared it, and for most of the decades since, Washington has been Israel’s most important friend, even when that friendship came with a short leash.
But Israel existed before American aid did. It won its War of Independence under an American arms embargo, with rifles from Czechoslovakia, and its soldiers have always done their own fighting. Gratitude is owed. Israel’s existence is not on loan.
After the midterm elections on November 3, the three most powerful men in Washington each performed an autopsy on the Republican rout. Two found Israel at the scene. Only one owned both the war and its cost, and he wasn’t the president or the man who openly wants to succeed him.
US President Donald Trump owns the war. He told 60 Minutes he would make the same choice again. But owning a decision means owning its cost, and here Trump flinched.
As Americans headed to the polls, he announced the end of America’s $4 billion in annual military aid to Israel. Ending the aid is defensible, and Trump says Netanyahu agreed to it.
Cutting it as the campaign closed, then telling Americans that dislike of Israel cost Republicans Congress, is something else.
The US and Israel launched this war together on February 28. It was Pete Hegseth, according to the Associated Press, who first told Trump it would be short, and Iran, not Israel, that closed the Strait of Hormuz.
Hegseth called the IDF “a true force multiplier.” CENTCOM commander Adm. Brad Cooper ranked the Israeli Air Force with America’s own as the best in the world.
Then there is Vice President JD Vance. “The reason we lost is the war,” he wrote on X/Twitter the morning after. Among his four proposed fixes: “change our relationship to Israel.”
Trump reminded everyone that Vance was “part of a decision-making process.” If the war cost Republicans Congress, Vance was one of the men who signed off on it. His fix is to punish the one ally that had no vote in that room.
Vance’s evidence was a private poll he hasn’t released. The polls we can see say otherwise. In a June Quinnipiac poll, 69% of Republicans called American support for Israel about right and another 6% wanted more.
Only 20% said it was too much. Vance is speaking to that fifth, the audience in Tucker Carlson’s comment sections and on the podcasts where Jewish influence explains everything they dislike.
In June, Vance helped negotiate the memorandum Trump signed with Iran at Versailles, built around a reopened Strait of Hormuz. It collapsed within weeks, after Iran began attacking ships.
In July, Vance’s explanation was that elements of the Israeli government tried to derail the talks. How that made Iran fire on tankers, he never explained.
In September, he declared that American policy cannot be “subservient to the state of Israel,” answering a charge no serious person had made.
He still won’t disavow Carlson, who says a demon clawed him in his sleep, gave Nick Fuentes a friendly platform, and now argues America should drop Israel as an ally. Carlson said he will always consider Vance a friend. Vance has given him no reason to reconsider.
None of Vance’s claims came with evidence. As I argued last week, America joining allies against a shared enemy is never called puppetry, except when the ally is Jewish.
Vance's fingerprints
Marco Rubio took the other road.
At Mar-a-Lago days after the midterm defeat, the secretary of state said Trump had confronted Iran when it would have been easier to “leave it for the next guy,” and that he was elected to make hard decisions even without political reward.
He owned the war as an American answer to a regime that has chanted “Death to America” for 47 years. He didn’t go looking for a Jewish state to blame.
On Thursday, Trump changed the subject. On Truth Social, he told Vance to give his “complete and total attention” to crime and corruption in blue states, and added: “We don’t need a deal with Iran. Those days have long since passed. We’ve got their money, Hundreds of Billions of Dollars, and we’ve got their Strait!”
Vance, the summer’s face of the Iran talks, has apparently been handed a different file. Perhaps the post-election talk about Israel was largely deflection for a bruised party, while the actual policy runs through the US Navy.
Trump has said that leaving Iran’s current rulers in power when his term ends “would be a failure,” and told Hugh Hewitt that a return to full-scale combat “could happen, it could happen.” Both doors are open: strangle the regime or finish it.
The blockade is already working. Since it was reimposed in July, Cooper said it has kept at least $25 billion in Iranian crude off the market, and IRGC and Basij members have reportedly gone months without pay.
The rial has fallen past 2.7 million to the dollar, and Iran’s own statistics agency put annual inflation at 88.7% in October. A kleptocracy that lives on oil pays its enforcers from the proceeds. When the oil stops moving, so do the paychecks of the men who beat protesters in the street.
Either way, the war Vance blamed for the defeat can still end in the victory it was fought for, with Israel as the partner that helped win it.
What voters punished was never the fighting. It was an April ceasefire Trump called a “total and complete victory” and a June deal that handed Iran a lifeline.
Vance is betting the loudest fifth of his party matters more than the three-quarters who stand with Israel, and that nobody will ask him for receipts. So ask.
Washington launched the war, Washington announced the ceasefire, and the deal that left Iran holding Hormuz carries Vance’s own fingerprints.
Rubio looked at that record and owned it. That is what a leader sounds like. Vance looked at it and found a Jewish state to blame.
That is Tucker Carlson with a security clearance: the woke Right’s grievance politics, with the Jews cast in their oldest role.
The writer is a contributing opinion writer for The Jerusalem Post and other Jewish publications, as well as an attorney, former IDF soldier, and former New York Police Department officer.